The study is concerned with Gender Literary Criticism and the teaching of German Literature in school and at university. The paper examines ‘close reading’ as one of the key methods in Gender Literary Studies and applies it to explore August von Platen’s poems to come to a better understanding of one of the most important German poets of the 19th century and demonstrate the essential meaning of Gender Literary Criticism for the development of a proper interpretative skill in class. The analysis is exemplified by a close reading of Platen’s homoerotic writings. The authors argue that exposing layers of public consciousness based on the assessment of an outstanding personality such as Platen can help de-stigmatise public attitudes and overcome a deep-rooted framework of public thinking.