Chatbots is the modern reality of consulting in medicine; [Чат-боты — современная реальность консультирования в медицине]

Introduction. Modern digital innovations and artificial intelligence technologies are being actively introduced in Medicine. Now chatbots are able to provide consulting services and make appointments for patients, make a diagnosis. Chatbots can significantly improve the efficiency and accuracy of symptom detection, assist in remote biomonitoring. Goal. To study the possibilities of development and directions of implementation of chatbots based on artificial intelligence technologies in medicine and to assess the potential of their application. Material and methods. The study is prospective, includes analysis of secondary information and conducting an expert interview on issues related to the development, application practice, and distribution of chatbots. Results. The survey showed most experts already to see the need to introduce chatbots in Medicine. The main advantages are: getting an “instant” response and saving patients’ time. The disadvantages of using chatbots may be: “incorrect interpretation” of both user requests and interpretation by patients. Experts see risks in the “erroneous” diagnosis and in the “measure of responsibility”. Limitations of research. The research materials are limited by the results of an expert survey conducted in 2023 and the quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the respondents who met the requirements for experts. Conclusions. Chatbots in the field of healthcare have already become a reality in consulting and providing the necessary medical information. Thanks to the development of information technologies, chatbots are able to process significant amounts of data received from patients, quickly and accurately find answers, provide information support, and establish a preliminary diagnosis. Such solutions can reduce the burden on medical professionals and increase patient satisfaction. © 2023 Meditsina Publishers. All rights reserved.

Авторы
Aksenova E.I. , Medvedeva E.I. , Kroshilin S.V.
Номер выпуска
5
Язык
Русский
Страницы
403-410
Статус
Опубликовано
Том
67
Год
2023
Организации
  • 1 Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management of Moscow Healthcare Department, Moscow, 115088, Russian Federation
  • 2 Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba, Moscow, 117198, Russian Federation
  • 3 Institute of Socio-Economic Studies of Population named after N.M. Rimashevskaya, Branch of the Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, 117218, Russian Federation
  • 4 I.P. Pavlov Ryazan State Medical University, Ryazan, 390026, Russian Federation
Ключевые слова
chatbots in medicine; healthcare organization; information and communication technologies in medicine; medical care; socio-economic problems
Цитировать
Поделиться

Другие записи

Alvarez E.M., Force L.M., Xu R., Compton K., Lu D., Henrikson H.J., Kocarnik J.M., Harvey J.D., Pennini A., Dean F.E., Fu W., Vargas M.T., Keegan T.H.M., Ariffin H., Barr R.D., Erdomaeva Y.A., Gunasekera D.S., John-Akinola Y.O., Ketterl T.G., Kutluk T., Malogolowkin M.H., Mathur P., Radhakrishnan V., Ries L.A.G., Rodriguez-Galindo C., Sagoyan G.B., Sultan I., Abbasi B., Abbasi-Kangevari M., Abbasi-Kangevari Z., Abbastabar H., Abdelmasseh M., Abd-Elsalam S., Abdoli A., Abebe H., Abedi A., Abidi H., Abolhassani H., Ali H.A., Abu-Gharbieh E., Achappa B., Acuna J.M., Adedeji I.A., Adegboye O.A., Adnani Q.E.S., Advani S.M., Afzal M.S., Meybodi M.A., Ahadinezhad B., Ahinkorah B.O., Ahmad S., Ahmadi S., Ahmed M.B., Rashid T.A., Salih Y.A., Aiman W., Akalu G.T., Hamad H.A., Alahdab F., AlAmodi A.A., Alanezi F.M., Alanzi T.M., Alem A.Z., Alem D.T., Alemayehu Y., Alhalaiqa F.N., Alhassan R.K., Ali S., Alicandro G., Alipour V., Aljunid S.M., Alkhayyat M., Alluri S., Almasri N.A., Al-Maweri S.A., Almustanyir S., Al-Raddadi R.M., Alvis-Guzman N., Ameyaw E.K., Amini S., Amu H., Ancuceanu R., Andrei C.L., Andrei T., Ansari F., Ansari-Moghaddam A., Anvari D., Anyasodor A.E., Arabloo J., Arab-Zozani M., Argaw A.M., Arshad M., Arulappan J., Aryannejad A., Asemi Z., Jafarabadi M.A., Atashzar M.R., Atorkey P., Atreya A., Attia S., Aujayeb A., Ausloos M., Avila-Burgos L., Awedew A.F., Quintanilla B.P.A., Ayele A.D., Ayen S.S., Azab M.A., Azadnajafabad S., Azami H., Azangou-Khyavy M., Jafari A.A., Azarian G., Azzam A.Y., Bahadory S., Bai J., Baig A.A., Baker J.L., Banach M., Bärnighausen T.W., Barone-Adesi F., Barra F., Barrow A., Basaleem H., Batiha A.-M.M., Behzadifar M., Bekele N.C., Belete R., Belgaumi U.I., Bell A.W., Berhie A.Y., Bhagat D.S., Bhagavathula A.S., Bhardwaj N., Bhardwaj P., Bhaskar S., Bhattacharyya K., Bhojaraja V.S., Bibi S., Bijani A., Biondi A., Birara S., Bjørge T., Bolarinwa O.A., Bolla S.R., Boloor A., Braithwaite D., Brenner H., Bulamu N.B., Burkart K., Bustamante-Teixeira M.T., Butt N.S., Butt Z.A., Dos Santos F.L.C., Cao C., Cao Y., Carreras G., Catalá-López F., Cembranel F., Cerin E., Chakinala R.C., Chakraborty P.A., Chattu V.K., Chaturvedi P., Chaurasia A., Chavan P.P., Chimed-Ochir O., Choi J.-Y.J., Christopher D.J., Chu D.-T., Chung M.T., Conde J., Costa V.M., Da O.B., Dadras O., Dahlawi S.M.A., Dai X., Damiani G., D'Amico E., Dandona L., Dandona R., Daneshpajouhnejad P., Darwish A.H., Daryani A., De La Hoz F.P., Debela S.A., Demie T.G.G., Demissie G.D., Demissie Z.G., Denova-Gutiérrez E., Molla M.D., Desai R., Desta A.A., Dhamnetiya D., Dharmaratne S.D., Dhimal M.L., Dhimal M., Dianatinasab M., Didehdar M., Diress M., Djalalinia S., Do H.P., Doaei S., Dorostkar F., Dos Santos W.M., Drake T.M., Ekholuenetale M., Sayed I.E., Zaki M.E.S., Tantawi M.E., El-Abid H., Elbahnasawy M.A., Elbarazi I., Elhabashy H.R., Elhadi M., El-Jaafary S.I., Enyew D.B., Erkhembayar R., Eshrati B., Eskandarieh S., Faisaluddin M., Fares J., Farooque U., Fasanmi A.O., Fatima W., De Oliveira J.M.P.F., Ferrero S., Desideri L.F., Fetensa G., Filip I., Fischer F., Fisher J.L., Foroutan M., Fukumoto T., Gaal P.A., Gad M.M., Gaewkhiew P., Gallus S., Garg T., Gebremeskel T.G., Gemeda B.N.B., Getachew T., Ghafourifard M., Ghamari S.-H., Ghashghaee A., Ghassemi F., Ghith N., Gholami A., Navashenaq J.G., Gilani S.A., Ginindza T.G., Gizaw A.T., Glasbey J.C., Goel A., Golechha M., Goleij P., Golinelli D., Gopalani S.V., Gorini G., Goudarzi H., Goulart B.N.G., Grada A., Gubari M.I.M., Guerra M.R., Guha A., Gupta B., Gupta S., Gupta V.B., Gupta V.K., Haddadi R., Hafezi-Nejad N., Hailu A., Haj-Mirzaian A., Halwani R., Hamadeh R.R., Hambisa M.T., Hameed S., Hamidi S., Haque S., Hariri S., Haro J.M., Hasaballah A.I., Hasan S.M.M., Hashemi S.M., Hassan T.S., Hassanipour S., Hay S.I., Hayat K., Hebo S.H., Heidari G., Heidari M., Herrera-Serna B.Y., Herteliu C., Heyi D.Z., Hezam K., Hole M.K., Holla R., Horita N., Hossain M.M., Hossain M.B., Hosseini M.-S., Hosseini M., Hosseinzadeh A., Hosseinzadeh M., Hostiuc M., Hostiuc S., Househ M., Hsairi M., Huang J., Hussein N.R., Hwang B.-F., Ibitoye S.E., Ilesanmi O.S., Ilic I.M., Ilic M.D., Innos K., Irham L.M., Islam R.M., Islam S.M.S., Ismail N.E., Isola G., Iwagami M., Jacob L., Jadidi-Niaragh F., Jain V., Jakovljevic M., Janghorban R., Mamaghani A.J., Jayaram S., Jayawardena R., Jazayeri S.B., Jebai R., Jha R.P., Joo T., Joseph N., Joukar F., Jürisson M., Kaambwa B., Kabir A., Kalankesh L.R., Kaliyadan F., Kamal Z., Kamath A., Kandel H., Kar S.S., Karaye I.M., Karimi A., Kassa B.G., Kauppila J.H., Bohan P.M.K., Kengne A.P., Kerbo A.A., Keykhaei M., Khader Y.S., Khajuria H., Khalili N., Khalili N., Khan E.A., Khan G., Khan M., Khan M.N., Khan M.A.B., Khanali J., Khayamzadeh M., Khosravizadeh O., Khubchandani J., Khundkar R., Kim M.S., Kim Y.J., Kisa A., Kisa S., Kissimova-Skarbek K., Kolahi A.-A., Kopec J.A., Koteeswaran R., Laxminarayana S.L.K., Koyanagi A., Kugbey N., Kumar G.A., Kumar N., Kwarteng A., Vecchia C.L., Lan Q., Landires I., Lasrado S., Lauriola P., Ledda C., Lee S.-W., Lee W.-C., Lee Y.Y., Lee Y.H., Leigh J., Leong E., Li B., Li J., Li M.-C., Lim S.S., Liu X., Lobo S.W., Loureiro J.A., Lugo A., Lunevicius R., El Razek H.M.A., El Razek M.M.A., Mahmoudi M., Majeed A., Makki A., Male S., Malekpour M.-R., Malekzadeh R., Malik A.A., Mamun M.A., Manafi N., Mansour-Ghanaei F., Mansouri B., Mansournia M.A., Martini S., Masoumi S.Z., Matei C.N., Mathur M.R., McAlinden C., Mehrotra R., Mendoza W., Menezes R.G., Mentis A.-F.A., Meretoja T.J., Mersha A.G., Mesregah M.K., Mestrovic T., Jonasson J.M., Miazgowski B., Michalek I.M., Miller T.R., Mingude A.B., Mirmoeeni S., Mirzaei H., Misra S., Mithra P., Mohammad K.A., Mohammadi M., Mohammadi S.M., Mohammadian-Hafshejani A., Mohammadpourhodki R., Mohammed A., Mohammed S., Mohammed T.A., Moka N., Mokdad A.H., Molokhia M., Momtazmanesh S., Monasta L., Moni M.A., Moradi G., Moradi Y., Moradzadeh M., Moradzadeh R., Moraga P., Morrison S.D., Mostafavi E., Khaneghah A.M., Mpundu-Kaambwa C., Mubarik S., Mwanri L., Nabhan A.F., Nagaraju S.P., Nagata C., Naghavi M., Naimzada M.D., Naldi L., Nangia V., Naqvi A.A., Swamy S.N., Narayana A.I., Nayak B.P., Nayak V.C., Nazari J., Nduaguba S.O., Negoi I., Negru S.M., Nejadghaderi S.A., Nepal S., Kandel S.N., Nggada H.A., Nguyen C.T., Nnaji C.A., Nosrati H., Nouraei H., Nowroozi A., Nuñez-Samudio V., Nwatah V.E., Nzoputam C.I., Oancea B., Odukoya O.O., Oguntade A.S., Oh I.-H., Olagunju A.T., Olagunju T.O., Olakunde B.O., Oluwasanu M.M., Omar E., Bali A.O., Ong S., Onwujekwe O.E., Ortega-Altamirano D.V., Otstavnov N., Otstavnov S.S., Oumer B., Owolabi M.O., Mahesh P.A., Padron-Monedero A., Padubidri J.R., Pakshir K., Pana A., Pandey A., Pardhan S., Pashazadeh F., Pasovic M., Patel J.R., Pati S., Pattanshetty S.M., Paudel U., Pereira R.B., Peres M.F.P., Perianayagam A., Postma M.J., Pourjafar H., Pourshams A., Prashant A., Pulakunta T., Fahd Qadir M.M.F., Rabiee M., Rabiee N., Radfar A., Radhakrishnan R.A., Rafiee A., Rafiei A., Rafiei S., Rahim F., Rahimzadeh S., Rahman M., Rahman M.A., Rahmani A.M., Rajesh A., Ramezani-Doroh V., Ranabhat K., Ranasinghe P., Rao C.R., Rao S.J., Rashedi S., Rashidi M., Rashidi M.-M., Rath G.K., Rawaf D.L., Rawaf S., Rawal L., Rawassizadeh R., Razeghinia M.S., Regasa M.T., Renzaho A.M.N., Rezaei M., Rezaei N., Rezaei N., Rezaeian M., Rezapour A., Rezazadeh-Khadem S., Riad A., Lopez L.E.R., Rodriguez J.A.B., Ronfani L., Roshandel G., Rwegerera G.M., Saber-Ayad M.M., Sabour S., Saddik B., Sadeghi E., Sadeghian S., Saeed U., Sahebkar A., Saif-Ur-Rahman K.M., Sajadi S.M., Salahi S., Salehi S., Salem M.R., Salimzadeh H., Samy A.M., Sanabria J., Sanmarchi F., Sarveazad A., Sathian B., Sawhney M., Sawyer S.M., Saylan M., Schneider I.J.C., Seidu A.-A., Šekerija M., Sendo E.G., Sepanlou S.G., Seylani A., Seyoum K., Sha F., Shafaat O., Shaikh M.A., Shamsoddin E., Shannawaz M., Sharma R., Sheikhbahaei S., Shetty A., Shetty B.S.K., Shetty P.H., Shin J.I., Shirkoohi R., Shivakumar K.M., Shobeiri P., Siabani S., Sibhat M.M., Malleshappa S.K.S., Sidemo N.B., Silva D.A.S., Julian G.S., Singh A.D., Singh J.A., Singh J.K., Singh S., Sinke A.H., Sintayehu Y., Skryabin V.Y., Skryabina A.A., Smith L., Sofi-Mahmudi A., Soltani-Zangbar M.S., Song S., Spurlock E.E., Steiropoulos P., Straif K., Subedi R., Sufiyan M.B., Abdulkader R.S., Sultana S., Szerencsés V., Szócska M., Tabaeian S.P., Tabarés-Seisdedos R., Tabary M., Tabuchi T., Tadbiri H., Taheri M., Taherkhani A., Takahashi K., Tampa M., Tan K.-K., Tat V.Y., Tavakoli A., Tbakhi A., Tehrani-Banihashemi A., Temsah M.-H., Tesfay F.H., Tesfaye B., Thakur J.S., Thapar R., Thavamani A., Thiyagarajan A., Thomas N., Tobe-Gai R., Togtmol M., Tohidast S.A., Tohidinik H.R., Tolani M.A., Tollosa D.N., Touvier M., Tovani-Palone M.R., Traini E., Tran B.X., Tran M.T.N., Tripathy J.P., Tusa B.S., Ukke G.G., Ullah I., Ullah S., Umapathi K.K., Unnikrishnan B., Upadhyay E., Ushula T.W., Vacante M., Tahbaz S.V., Varthya S.B., Veroux M., Villeneuve P.J., Violante F.S., Vlassov V., Vu G.T., Waheed Y., Wang N., Ward P., Weldesenbet A.B., Wen Y.F., Westerman R., Winkler A.S., Wubishet B.L., Xu S., Jabbari S.H.Y., Yang L., Yaya S., Yazdi-Feyzabadi V., Yazie T.S., Yehualashet S.S., Yeshaneh A., Yeshaw Y., Yirdaw B.W., Yonemoto N., Younis M.Z., Yousefi Z., Yu C., Yunusa I., Zadnik V., Zahir M., Moghadam T.Z., Zamani M., Zamanian M., Zandian H., Zare F., Zastrozhin M.S., Zastrozhina A., Zhang J., Zhang Z.-J., Ziapour A., Zoladl M., Murray C.J.L., Fitzmaurice C., Bleyer A., Bhakta N.
The Lancet Oncology. Том 23. 2022. С. 27-52