Comparison of the desiccation effects of marine and freshwater diatomaceous earths on insects

The desiccating effects of two different types of diatomaceous earths (DEs), of freshwater and marine origin, applied by two different methods, were compared on four species of insects, Cryptolestes ferrugineus, Rhyzopertha dominica, Sitophilus oryzae and Sitophilus granarius. The purpose was to investigate the performance of DEs, including their abrasive and absorptive effects through the accumulation of silica dusts on the insect cuticle, resulting in death of the insects by desiccation. The data obtained showed that similar insects treated with the same type of diatom, but applied either by spraying or dusting, did not have the same initial mortality rate. After examining and comparing the data obtained, it appeared that weight loss at death of insects subjected to the action of sprayed DEs was slightly less than for insects subjected to dust application, while mortality was slightly more rapid during the observation period. The extra weight of dusted insects was ascribed to greater adherence of dust particles to the treated insects. © 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.